
One should reserve ankle replacement for patients who do not perform heavy manual labor, are over the age of 45 (preferably over the age of 55) and have little to no ankle deformity. Although surgeons may correct some level of ankle deformity with soft tissue or bone realignment procedures, the ankle replacement patient of choice is one with an arthritic ankle that is well aligned. Of interest is the fact that patients who have arthritic hindfoot joints about the ankle seem to do better with an ankle replacement than an ankle fusion. This is due to the fact that an ankle fusion places greater stress on the surrounding joints, which may lead to further arthritic changes of the hindfoot joints. In contrast, an ankle replacement allows motion at the ankle, resulting in less strain on the surrounding joints.
What is involved in the preoperative assessment for ankle replacement?
The preoperative assessment for ankle replacement involves a thorough evaluation of the patient's vascular, neurologic, and dermatologic status, along with the function and alignment of the foot and leg's muscles, ligaments, tendons, and bones. This assessment ensures the patient is a viable candidate, addressing factors like poor circulation, neuropathy, skin quality, and existing laxity or non-functioning tendons. Standard radiographs are often sufficient, but MRI or CT scans may be ordered for potential cystic changes, avascular necrosis, or severe arthritis in surrounding joints to determine the best procedure (replacement vs. fusion).
Weighing Mobile Bearing Versus Fixed Ankle Options
Currently, our institute utilizes two different ankle replacement options. The INBONE® Total Ankle Replacement (Wright Medical) is a fixed ankle replacement while the Scandinavian Total Ankle Replacement (STAR™, Small Bone Innovations) is a mobile bearing option. We have seen excellent results with both devices and they both have pros and cons. In regard to the main difference between a fixed and a mobile bearing ankle replacement, with the mobile bearing option, the plastic spacer material is not attached to the talar or tibial component, and floats in between the two. This allows for some varus and valgus tilt, and there may be less stress during movement on the metal-bone attachment point of the implant. This results in less loosening. The fixed option has a plastic spacer, which is attached to the tibial component. This spacer does not allow varus or valgus tilt, but allows for a long stem insertion into the tibia. This may add strength and prevent subsidence. The choice of implant is a difficult one to make. The STAR implant is a very low profile device and has an excellent potential for conversion to either a fusion or larger ankle replacement in the case of a problem. On the other hand, the INBONE option has a good implantation guidance system and the long tibial stem allows for strong tibial stabilization. In our experience, both systems have had excellent results and are fairly easy to insert after one masters a learning curve. In our institute, we have begun to use the STAR ankle replacement in stable and simple ankle replacement cases that require minimal soft tissue or bony procedures. The STAR also has a more stable talar component, which we prefer in cases of severe talus arthritic changes or severe medial and lateral gutter arthritis. It is still unclear if there is a major benefit to a three-piece mobile bearing implant. On the other hand, if there are any cystic changes in the tibia or if there is a previous distal tibial fracture and the bone is not ideal, we prefer the INBONE ankle replacement as it has a far more stable tibial component. Also, the INBONE ankle replacement has a better surgical guidance system, which allows better positioning in more difficult ankles. Finally, in the case of a previously failed ankle replacement that requires revision, the INBONE is our preferred system.
What are the key conclusions for ankle replacement patient selection and outcomes?
The key conclusions for ankle replacement patient selection and outcomes emphasize that patient selection and proper surgical procedure are essential for ideal results. While advancements continue, the choice between mobile bearing and fixed bearing options depends on the specific case: mobile bearing is preferred for straightforward cases or severe talar/gutter arthritis, while the more stable fixed bearing is chosen for tibial cystic changes, deformed tibias, revision cases, or difficult alignments. Both types have shown excellent results in practice.
Dr. Baravarian is an Assistant Clinical Professor at the UCLA School of Medicine. He is the Chief of Podiatric Foot and Ankle Surgery at the Santa Monica UCLA Medical Center and Orthopedic Hospital, and is the Director of the University Foot and Ankle Institute in Los Angeles.
Dr. Morris is a faculty member of the University Foot and Ankle Institute, and practices in the Santa Barbara Institute.
Reference
- Deorio JK, Easley ME. Total ankle arthroplasty. Instr Course Lect. 2008; 57:383-413.